How to Defend Yourself in a Car Accident Lawsuit
What happens when you're sued after a car accident
When someone sues you over a car accident, you have received a complaint — a formal document filed with the court that lists what the other person claims you did and what they want in damages. You do not have to settle. You can defend yourself in court, and the process has specific steps and important date you must follow or you lose the right to defend yourself at all.
The first thing that happens is you receive the complaint and a summons, which tells you how long you have to respond — usually 20 to 30 days depending on your state. If you miss that important date, the court can enter a default judgment against you, meaning the judge rules in the other person's favor without hearing your side. That is why the important date is the single most important date in the case.
Your response to the complaint is called an answer. In it, you admit or deny each claim the other person made. You can also raise affirmative defenses — legal reasons why you should not be held responsible even if some of what they said is true. For example, if they were jaywalking or speeding, that may reduce or eliminate their damages even if you were also at fault.
Key Takeaways
- You must respond to the complaint within 20 to 30 days or the court will rule against you by default without hearing your case.
- Your response, called an answer, requires you to admit or deny each claim and raise any legal defenses that explore to your situation.
- Your insurance company will usually pay for a lawyer to defend you, but you must notify them when ready and provide them with the complaint.
- Most cases settle before trial, but you should prepare for trial in case settlement talks fail.
- Discovery — the exchange of documents and witness statements — is where most cases are won or lost, not in the courtroom.
Notify your insurance company when ready
Call your insurance company the moment you receive the complaint. Do not wait. Your policy almost certainly includes defense coverage, which means the insurer will hire and pay for a lawyer to defend you. That lawyer works for you, not the insurance company, though the insurer pays the bill.
Bring the complaint and summons to that call. The insurance company will open a claim file and assign you a claim number. They will then assign a defense attorney from their panel of lawyers — attorneys they work with regularly. You can usually request a different lawyer if you have a strong reason, but the insurer picks the lawyer, not you.
Do not hire your own lawyer and then expect the insurance company to pay for both yours and theirs. That creates a conflict. If you hire a lawyer before notifying the insurer, you may end up paying out of pocket. Let the insurer assign counsel first.
Understanding what discovery means and why it matters
Discovery is the phase where both sides exchange documents, photos, medical records, repair estimates, and written questions called interrogatories. You will also sit for a deposition — a recorded question-and-answer session with the other side's lawyer, usually lasting a few hours. Your own lawyer will prepare you for this.
Discovery is where most cases are decided. If the other person's medical records show a pre-existing injury, or if their repair estimate is inflated, or if their own statements contradict what they claimed in the complaint, your lawyer will find it here. Conversely, if your insurance company's investigation found you were clearly at fault, the other side will find that too.
You must respond to discovery requests on time — usually within 30 days. If you ignore them, the judge can order you to pay the other side's legal fees and can even rule against you. Your lawyer will handle most of this, but you will need to gather documents they ask for and answer written questions truthfully.
How your insurance company's investigation affects your defense
Your insurer will have already investigated the accident before the lawsuit arrived — they did that when you filed your claim. That investigation report becomes part of your defense. It includes the police report, photos of vehicle damage, witness statements, and the adjuster's opinion on fault.
If that investigation shows you were not at fault or only partially at fault, your lawyer will use it to argue for dismissal or a lower settlement. If it shows you were clearly at fault, your lawyer will focus on limiting damages — arguing that the other person's injuries were not as severe as they claim, or that their medical treatment was unnecessary.
Be honest with your lawyer about what happened. If you were speeding, or distracted, or violated a traffic law, tell your lawyer. They already assume the worst and will build a defense around the truth. Lying to your own lawyer weakens your case and can get them removed from representing you.
Responding to settlement offers during the lawsuit
Most car accident lawsuits settle before trial. The other side may make an offer at any point — after you file your answer, during discovery, or even days before trial. Your lawyer will present each offer to you and explain what it means.
You do not have to accept any settlement. But understand that if you reject an offer and then lose at trial, you may owe more than what was offered. Your lawyer should tell you the strengths and weaknesses of your case so you can make an informed decision.
If you do settle, the other person signs a release — a document saying they will not sue you again over this accident. The settlement amount is usually confidential, meaning neither side can publicly discuss what was paid.
What to expect if the case goes to trial
If settlement fails, the case goes to trial. A judge or jury will hear evidence from both sides. Your lawyer will present your defense, cross-examine the other side's witnesses, and argue why you should not be held liable or why damages should be lower.
You may have to testify. Your lawyer will prepare you for questions from both your own attorney and the other side's lawyer. You will be under oath, and lying under oath is perjury — a criminal offense.
Trial usually takes one to five days for a car accident case. The judge or jury then decides whether you are liable and, if so, how much you owe. You have the right to appeal if you believe the judge made a legal error, though appeals are expensive and rarely succeed.
Protecting yourself if you do not have insurance
If you were uninsured when the accident happened, you do not have a defense lawyer paid for. You can still defend yourself in court, but you will have to hire your own lawyer and pay out of pocket, or represent yourself — which is risky and not recommended.
Some states allow you to request a court-appointed lawyer if you cannot afford one, but this is rare in civil cases and more common in criminal cases. Ask the court clerk whether your state offers this.
If you lose and owe a judgment, the other person can garnish your wages, place a lien on your home, or seize your bank accounts — depending on your state's laws. This is why having insurance matters: it protects your personal assets.
Frequently Asked Questions
What if I ignore the lawsuit and do not respond?
The court will enter a default judgment against you, meaning you lose automatically without a hearing. The other person then has a court order to collect from you. You can ask the court to set aside the default if you have a good reason for missing the important date, but this is difficult and expensive. Respond on time.
Can I represent myself instead of using the lawyer my insurance company assigned?
Yes, you can fire the assigned lawyer and hire your own, but you will pay for your own lawyer out of pocket. Your insurance company will still pay for your defense under the policy, but only up to the policy limit. If your own lawyer's fees exceed that, you pay the difference. Most people use the assigned counsel.
What if the other person's injuries seem exaggerated?
That is what discovery is for. Your lawyer will request their medical records, deposition testimony, and treatment history. If the records show minimal injury but they are claiming major damages, your lawyer will use that to argue for a lower settlement or judgment. Do not accuse them of lying — let the evidence speak.
Can the other person sue me for more than what my insurance covers?
Yes. If your policy limit is $100,000 and the judgment is $150,000, you owe the extra $50,000 personally. This is called going "over policy limits." It is one reason to carry higher limits than the state minimum. Your lawyer will discuss this risk with you during settlement negotiations.
How long does a car accident lawsuit usually take?
From complaint to settlement or trial, most cases take one to three years. Discovery alone can take six months to a year. If the case is straightforward and both sides agree on fault, it may settle in a few months. Complex cases with serious injuries take longer.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.