Skip to main content

HomeAll guides

What Happens to a Pain and Suffering Claim When the Plaintiff Dies in Colorado

Colorado law ends pain and suffering claims when the plaintiff dies

In Colorado, a claim for pain and suffering dies with the person who experienced it. If the injured person passes away before the case settles or goes to trial, the family cannot recover money for the pain, emotional distress, or loss of enjoyment of life that the deceased person endured. This is different from other damages — medical bills, lost wages, and funeral expenses can still be claimed by the estate — but subjective suffering cannot be transferred to heirs or a wrongful death claim.

This rule exists because Colorado courts treat pain and suffering as personal to the injured person. Once that person is gone, the law assumes there is no one to have suffered, and no one to compensate for that suffering. The rule applies whether the person dies before filing a lawsuit, during settlement negotiations, or even after a judgment but before payment.

The timing of death matters significantly for what the family can recover. Understanding the difference between what is lost and what remains available helps families and their representatives make decisions about settling or continuing a case.

Key Takeaways

  • Pain and suffering damages cannot be recovered in Colorado if the injured person dies, even if the death is unrelated to the original injury.
  • Medical expenses, lost wages, and funeral costs can still be claimed through the estate or a wrongful death action, but not pain and suffering.
  • If a settlement offer includes pain and suffering money and the plaintiff dies before accepting, that portion of the offer is typically lost.
  • Families should discuss the timing of a potential settlement with their attorney if the plaintiff's health is declining, because waiting may eliminate part of the claim's value.

What damages survive the plaintiff's death in Colorado

Colorado distinguishes between economic damages and non-economic damages when someone dies. Economic damages — the actual out-of-pocket costs — survive and can be claimed by the estate or pursued in a wrongful death lawsuit. These include unpaid medical bills from the injury, lost wages the person would have earned, and reasonable funeral and burial expenses.

Non-economic damages are the subjective ones: pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, disfigurement, and loss of consortium (the loss of companionship a spouse or family member experiences). In Colorado, these do not survive the plaintiff's death. If the injured person dies, those claims vanish.

A wrongful death claim — filed by the family if the injury itself caused the death — is a separate action with its own damages. But even in wrongful death cases, the family cannot recover for the deceased person's pain and suffering from the original injury. They can recover for their own loss of companionship and support, but that is different from the deceased person's subjective experience.

How the timing of death affects settlement negotiations

If a settlement offer is on the table and the plaintiff dies before accepting it, the offer typically becomes void. The defendant is no longer liable for pain and suffering damages, which may have made up a significant portion of the offer. The family's attorney will need to renegotiate based on what remains: economic damages only.

This creates a real financial consequence. A settlement offer of $100,000 might include $40,000 for pain and suffering and $60,000 for medical bills and lost wages. If the plaintiff dies before signing, the family may only be able to recover the $60,000 portion, or possibly less if the defendant argues the case is now weaker.

For this reason, families facing a declining plaintiff's health should discuss timing with their attorney. Settling quickly, while the plaintiff is alive, preserves the pain and suffering component. Waiting to see if a better offer comes may backfire if the plaintiff's condition worsens.

What happens if the plaintiff dies during trial

If the case goes to trial and the plaintiff dies before a verdict is reached, the trial typically stops. The case does not automatically continue with the family as plaintiffs. Instead, the family's attorney must decide whether to pursue a wrongful death claim (if the injury caused the death) or attempt to recover the remaining economic damages through the estate.

The jury will not award pain and suffering damages for a deceased plaintiff, even if the trial was already underway. Any verdict would be limited to economic losses and, in a wrongful death case, the family's own losses from losing the deceased person.

This is another reason why settling before the plaintiff's health becomes critical can protect the family's financial recovery. A settlement locks in the full value; a trial does not.

The difference between Colorado's rule and other states

Some states allow pain and suffering claims to survive death and be pursued by the estate. Colorado does not. This is a significant difference if the injured person is from out of state or if the case involves multi-state issues. The location where the injury occurred and where the lawsuit is filed determines which state's law applies.

If you are dealing with a case that involves Colorado law but the plaintiff is from another state, or vice versa, the rules can become complicated. An attorney familiar with Colorado law and the specific circumstances is necessary to understand what can and cannot be claimed.

Steps to take if the plaintiff's health is declining

If the injured person's condition is worsening, the family and attorney should review the current settlement offers and the strength of the case. The attorney can estimate what the pain and suffering portion of a potential recovery might be and weigh that against the risk of losing it entirely if the plaintiff dies.

The family should also may support that all economic damages are documented: medical records, bills, pay stubs, and receipts. These will be needed whether the case settles or continues as a wrongful death claim. The attorney may recommend accepting a settlement offer that is lower than hoped for, but certain, rather than risking a larger verdict that could disappear if the plaintiff dies before trial.

If the plaintiff does pass away, the family should notify the attorney when ready. The attorney will then determine what claims remain available and what the next steps are.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the family recover pain and suffering if the plaintiff dies from a different cause than the original injury?

No. Colorado law does not allow pain and suffering damages to be recovered if the plaintiff dies, regardless of the cause of death. Even if the person dies from an unrelated illness or accident, the pain and suffering claim from the original injury is lost. Only economic damages remain.

What if there was already a judgment for pain and suffering but the plaintiff dies before receiving payment?

If a judgment has been entered and includes pain and suffering damages, the family may be able to collect that judgment as part of the estate. However, if the plaintiff dies before a judgment is final, the situation is different. The family should consult an attorney about whether the judgment can be enforced or whether it is affected by the death.

Can a wrongful death claim recover pain and suffering from the original injury?

No. A wrongful death claim allows the family to recover for their own loss of companionship and support, but not for the deceased person's pain and suffering from the original injury. These are two separate claims with different rules.

Should we settle quickly if the plaintiff is very ill?

That depends on the specific offer, the strength of the case, and the plaintiff's wishes. Your attorney can help weigh the certainty of a settlement against the risk of losing pain and suffering damages if the plaintiff dies. There is no one-size-fit-all answer, but the risk is real and should be part of the conversation.

Does Colorado law change if the plaintiff is a minor?

No. The rule applies to all plaintiffs, regardless of age. If a minor is injured and dies before the case settles, pain and suffering damages are lost. Economic damages can still be claimed through the estate or a wrongful death action.

This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.